England vs. West Indies ODI series : The Talking Points

By Mary Meyer

PA-13822990.jpg

Ian Bell struck a majestic century as England beat West Indies in the first ODI

Is a white-wash on the cards?

England are firm favourites for tomorrow’s match at The Oval after going one nil up in the series in Southampton on Saturday. However, West Indies skipper Darren Sammy said last week that his side expect to win the series and there is still a chance that Headingley will play host to a decider this Friday. The Caribbean side will be buoyed by the return of prodigal batsman Chris Gayle in South London and should give England a stern test if conditions are more conducive to cricket than they were at the weekend. Alastair Cook’s side is still very much in its infancy and remains vulnerable; the 4-0 series win over Pakistan in February followed a 5-0 defeat in India last October. The thirteen one-dayers this summer against West Indies, Australia and South Africa will determine the shape of the squad ahead of the 2015 World Cup. Continue reading

Share


More batting woes put England on the brink of losing all they worked for

England fell to their fourth consecutive test match defeat today to leave their status as number one in the world in dire jeopardy.

Bell's form and demeanour has resembled 2005, when he was dominated by Shane Warne

If they fail to win the second and final Test of the series against Sri Lanka next week, they will cede their position to the rampant South Africans, who tour England in the second part of the summer.

The performance in Galle was typical of the winter England have had in this form of the game. Excellent bowling was undermined by some at times woeful batting, with England passing 300 on just one occasion in eight innings so far. The second innings performance in this match was by no means the worst of the winter, but it was error-strewn enough to suggest that this England side are in decline.

Ian Bell’s first innings half century was a welcome return to some sort of form, having endured the most torrid time against Saeed Ajmal in the UAE. England fans can only hope that this is the start of another upward trend akin to 2011, when he averaged over 100, rather than a peak among a terminal trough.

Bell is the personification of England’s long term problems in playing spin in the sub-continent. A lack of a game plan, timid in defence and unsure in attack, the Warwickshire batsman regresses to his former ‘Shermanator’ identity, as Shane Warne unkindly christened him, as soon as a spinner of any sort of quality comes on to bowl. How he has gone from arguably the most in-form player in the world eight months ago to this is anyone’s guess.

Of the other batsmen, it would appear to be only captain Andrew Strauss who is under pressure. Jonathan Trott scored a brilliant century in the second innings, while it seems that Alastair Cook has got enough runs in stock to take him through to retirement, such has been his form in the last two years. Kevin Pietersen has had a lean winter in white clothing, but his form in the 50 and 20 over forms of the game was a reminder of him at his very best.

So Strauss, the man who led England so expertly in capturing the giant mace that signified their ascent to the top of the rankings, is suddenly the subject of scrutiny for his place. He has now gone some 24 innings without a Test match century, his last three figure score coming at Brisbane in November 2010.

The skipper has five half centuries in that time, and has made it past to double figures on 17 occasions during the lean spell, suggesting that his form is far from chronic, but England need their leader to make big hundreds and dictate an innings, not make 20 or 30 pretty runs and give it away, as was the case yesterday.

Any calls for Strauss to lose his place are hugely reactive. Yes his run of form is not ideal, and the fact that England are losing games rather than winning them further spotlights his personal failings, but to remove him now would cause far more harm than good. His Ashes record means that he must be in charge for the visit of Australia next summer at the very least.

And so we go to Colombo, with England battling to save the crown that they fought so hard to earn. Over the last four years, this England side have displayed guts and brilliance that has not been seen by cricket fans in this country for more than a generation. They haven’t become a bad side in the last four months, but they need to rediscover the basic skill set of batting according to the situation if they are to recapture anywhere near there best form.

Defeat in Asia is hardly a new phenomenon for England – a loss in the home series against the West Indies would be something to worry about.

Share


Batsmen must learn that it’s tough at the top

Morgan on the brink of a spell out of the side

It all seemed fairly inconceivable in August. Back then, when the sun was warm, the wind was refreshing and the evenings stayed bright, the cricketing landscape in England looked rosy.

Andrew Strauss’ team had just completed a comprehensive 4-0 series victory over India to take their place at the top of cricket’s world rankings. The best-laid plans had come together better than anyone could have imagined. Continue reading

Share


Hot to Trott? Perhaps not

Batsman the target of heavy criticism despite consistent results

It is very much the English way to jump on a bandwagon. “The team are losing, lets knock them down further”. “He is out of form – lets all attack him”. But the newest phenomenon, it appears, is knocking our best players. It has happened with Kevin Pietersen, who has been criticised heavily in this series for not going on to a century despite three scores of over 40. And now it is the turn of Jonathan Trott. Continue reading

Share


Big hitters: Who will top England’s run race in India

Bopara et al fight it out as competition hots up

When analysing the Natwest one day series between England and India this summer, it would be easy to assume that given the 3-0 score line, it was English batsmen who dominated proceedings. This is not the case. In fact, of the top five run scorers, only one is English. Ravi Bopara enjoyed a profitable time, making 197 runs in his four matches. His average of 65.66 is more than 20 runs higher than the next best.

The top two run scorers of the series were Indian. MS Dhoni topped the list, hitting 236 at 78.66, while Suresh Raina made 198. Sandwiching Bopara in the top five are Virat Kholi and Parthiv Patel, who scored 194 and 172 runs respectively.

The big question is which England batsman will score the most runs in the forthcoming series in India? Can Bopara carry on his fine form from the summer – will he even make it into the team?

Alastair Cook leads the side after a good return in the last series, making 169 runs at 42.25. Craig Keiswetter faces stiff competition to keep his place. Keiswetter averaged 27.20 in the India series, and is not guaranteed a start with the arrival of Jonny Bairstow on the scene as potential wicket-keeper batsmen.

Jonny Bairstow has made quite the impact in his embryonic international career

Continue reading

Share